Ohr Torah Stone Home Page

Yeshivat Hamivtar Orot Lev
Yeshivat Hamivtar Orot Lev
Yeshivat Hamivtar Orot Lev
Yeshivat Hamivtar Orot Lev Home Page
About us
Leadership Seminary
Rabbinical Seminary
Amiel
YHOL Application Form
Contact us

Ohr Torah Stone
1x1transp.gif (807 bytes) 1x1transp.gif (807 bytes) 1x1transp.gif (807 bytes)

Tisha Be'Av

Rambam in Bet Habechira (BH) chap 1 halacha one,  states categorically:

It is a positive commandment to make a "house" for Hashem. It will stand ready for sacrifices, and the people will assemble there three times a year, and this directive is reflected in the verse (shmot25:8) "and they will make for me a Temple (Tabernacle).Note:  The verse is specifically about the Tabernacle but applies also to the building of the Temple.

In halacha 6,  Rambam continues:  There are vessels in the Temple. First amongst them is the altar for the burnt offering and the other sacrifices.

It seems that the altar is a function of the "house".  Build a house for Hashem and it will contain an altar. 

Note.  I do not refer here to the dispute about what was made first the "house"or the "vessels", which comes to the fore at the end of the book of Shmot.  I am only mentioning the order as presented in the Rambam.  The "house" has a specific verse while the altar does not;  the Rambam's opinion is that they go together.

Halacha 3.  When the Temple was built in Yerushalayim, all the other places became forbidden. You could not build a house anywhere else, nor could you sacrifice anywhere else. The house that would last forever (the place certainly), was in Yerushalyim and the place of sacrifice was on Mount Moriah.

There is ultimately a connection between the "house" and the altar.  Once the house has been built,  the sacrifices can not be given anywhere else.  This in spite of the fact that before the "house" was built in Yerusalayim,  the sacrifices were given in any place that in which an altar was built. There was no necessary connection between the "house" and the sacrifices until the "house" was established.

Rambam in chapter 2, halacha 2 adds a historical point.

There is a well known tradition that the place that the altar was established by the kings David and Shlomo was the very place that Avraham built the altar to sacrifice his son Yizhaq.  And that in turn,  was the place that Noach built his altar when he came out of the ark. And that is the very altar that Kayyin and Hevel were using when they sacrificed to Hashem.  In fact (Rambam adds) it was the very place that Adam the first man sacrificed, and he was created from that place  (The sacrifice given by Adam is not mentioned in the Torah, but is clearly stated by chazal).  The chachamim have pointed out the following insight (yerushalmi nazir 7:2): Man was created (the dust of creation came ) from the place of his atonement (the place where in the future sacrifices would be given).  The dust was from the place of the altar which was an ongoing source of kapara.

Sacrifice is the result of a human need.  Either the need to thank heaven in a tangible way,  or the need to seek some sort of accommodation with heaven.  The connections while not obvious certainly exist.  The altar is the building which takes into account man's needs and his weaknesses.  At first man could sacrifice in any place; again and again he chose to sacrifice in a special place, Mount Moriah.  There was always the sense that there was a right place, a place which would make the sacrifice more effective. The place from which the dust of creation was collected was understood to be that place.  We know of this place because we are directed to use that knowledge in an effective way.    This place was known to the people in their memory but they were not able to actualize this memory, until the "house" was actually built. For Adam, Noach, and Avraham there were no impediments.  They could go to the place and sacrifice to Hashem.  For the people, when entering the land it became clear that they would not gain access to Moriah till the "house" had been built.  A new relationship had been established; the "house" was demanded.   Following the building of the "house"  there was a new altar which was built by man but fixed in the place of Hashem. The altar was built on Moriah, but Moriah had now become the place of Hashem and the "house" His house.   This altar could not be replaced by a similar structure that would exist outside the house.  When the house was destroyed  it was clear to all that the altar could be rebuilt unless and untill the house would be rebuilt with it.

The destruction of the "house" devastated the people because they could not return to the state of Adam and Avraham who had an altar whenever they desired to sacrifice.  The building of the "house" demanded new levels of responsibility.  This responsibility was not fulfilled and the temple was destroyed.

An easy fast

In England:  Well over the fast

 

Return to Home